Denying Jewish Past

Assuming that Jewish geography is illegitimate.
Assuming that any Jewish historical narrative is illegitimate.
Assuming that Jewish nationality is intrinsically illegitimate.
Claiming that American Jewry is illegitimate due to its ties with Israel.
Assuming that Zionists but not Arabists are responsible for acts of their forebears.
“There were never calls from Arabist leaders to throw the Jews in the sea.”
“The Shoah never occurred.”
“It is impossible to tell how many Jews were killed during WWII.”
“There was never any Jewish temple in Jerusalem.”
“Modern Israel was founded as a colony.”
“Modern Israel was founded on White supremacism.”
“There was no Jewish nation in antiquity.”
“There was no Jewish nation in the Diaspora.”
“Judea and Samaria are inappropriate names for the West Bank.”
“The Arabist leaders of the time bear no responsibility whatsoever for the Holocaust.”
“There was no significant Amian immigration to British Palestine.”
“Palestine precedes Israel.”
“There has never been a Jewish-Palestinian conflict, only one-sided victimization.”
“The Palestinians have always existed as a national group throughout recorded history.”
“Jewish geography is a colonial invention.”
“The Jews of Arabophone countries were ethnic Arabists.”
“Writing Jewish history per se constitutes historical fabrication.”
“Palestinian leaders did not collaborate with Nazi Germany.”
“There is no history of Anti-Jewish aversions among Palestinians.”
“It is offensive to refer to Palestinians as Arabs.”
“There is no history of support for anti-democratic movements among Palestinians.”
“Zionist immigration introduced a people completely new to the land.”
“The notion of a Rabbinical Jewish Diaspora from Israel is a Zionist invention.”
“The pre-state Zionists generally regarded Israel as almost completely unpopulated.”
“Israel is not and has never been a liberal democracy.”
“Jordan was never part of British Palestine.”
“Arabist regimes have not used Palestinians for domestic Anti-Jewish aversions.”
“Israel has always denied the Palestinians self-determination.”
“The Israel Defence Forces have never practiced purity of arms.”
“American Zionist Jews have greatly harmed American national interests.”
“The national terminology ‘Palestinian’ was introduced as an Arabist ethnonym.”
“Jerusalem has always been the third holiest city in Islam.”
“Jerusalem is mentioned in the Quran.”
“Justice requires the writing of Near Eastern gentiles only history.”
“Jews who relocated to Judea/Samaria after the 1967 war displaced Palestinian Amians.”
“There has been no historically significant Muslim immigration to Palestine.”
“The Jews are a non-native population in Israel and the West Bank, including Judea.”
“Israel was created by gentiles as reparations for the Holocaust.”
“Western media has never given much attention to Palestinian suffering.”
“There has never been a history of Anti-Jewish aversions among Palestinians.”
“There was never any systematic persecution of Jews in Muslim lands.”
“There has never been a history of Anti-Jewish aversions in the Muslim world.”
“Mizrahi Jews generally identified with the ethnicity of the Muslim majority.”
“Mizrahi Jews who emigrated from Muslim countries had no reason to hold fear.”
“Most of the 1948 Palestinian refugees escaped Jewish persecution.”
“The Holy land had a high density of population in the late 19th century.”
“Palestinian identification with a Palestinian territorial unit preceded Zionism.
“Organized Arabist nationalism preceded organized Jewish nationalism.”
“Arabism preceded Zionism.”
“Palestinians have generally been stereotyped as terrorists.”
“Palestinian suffering has been underreported as opposed to other armed conflicts.”
“Israel and the US publically designated the religion of Islam as the enemy.”
“There was no basis for Jewish fears of Arabist genocide in 1940’s and later.”
“The United States has for many years provided uncritical support for Israel.”
“Palestinian nationalism preceded Jewish nationalism.”
“Jewish history is religious while gentile history is secular.”
“There was no de facto exchange of population between Israel and its neighbours.”
“Jews of Arabophone countries did not immigrate to Israel due to Muslim persecution.”
“Arabists carry no responsibility for refusing Jews asylum in the period of 1939-45.”
“Palestinians carry no responsibility for refusing Jews asylum in the period of 1939-45.”
“Muslims carry no responsibility for refusing Jews asylum in the period of 1939-45.”
“Palestinians have no responsibility whatsoever for the Holocaust.”
“Pre-state Jewish immigrants generally displaced Palestinians.”
“There has been no majoritarian Palestinian public support for ethnic murder.”
“There have never been expulsions of Palestinians from Arabist polities.”
“Israel was defeated in southern Lebanon.”
“Modern Muslim regimes have not generally used Anti-Zionism as a political tool.”
“The PLO has officially advocated a bi-national one-state solution.
“There was no massive mutual Arabist-Zionist dispossession in the period of 1947-51.
“The Arabist side was unilaterally dispossessed by the Zionist side.”
“There has been no significant public incitement to ethnic murder in PA schools.”
“There was a tactically consistent policy of expulsion of Palestinians in 1948.”
“There was a plan in 1948 to expel all Palestinians.”
“Israel deliberately planned Palestinian underdevelopment.”
“PLO leaders negotiated Israeli-Palestinian accords with Holocaust survivors.”
“Zionism did not receive international recognition until after WWII.
“Zionism received international recognition mainly on account of the Holocaust.”
“Most Israeli leaders were Holocaust survivors.”
“Zionism had no legal international legitimacy before WWII.”
“Zionism had no standing in international law before WWII.”
“Israel has never established a single Amian residential community in Israel”
“Western supporters of Israel viewed its establishment as restitution for the Holocaust.”
“Western supporters of Israel viewed its establishment as restitution for Anti-Semitism.”
“The PLO was created for the purpose of establishing a Palestinian state.”
“The PLO was founded for the purpose of reaching peace with Israel.”
“Zionism has stifled political discussion and silenced civil opposition.”
“Zionism has systematically misrepresented the Palestinians.”
“Zionists generally believed that the land was almost completely uninhabited.
“Zionists generally claimed that the land was almost completely uninhabited.”
“The Holocaust was a trivial event.”
“Holocaust denial is trivial.”
“Apartheid is inherent to Zionism.”
“The Zionists gained European and American prior approval for expelling Palestinians.”
“Europeans and American were behind the Palestinian Nakba.”
“Western nations were behind the Palestinian Nakba.”
“Only Jews have been allowed to immigrate to Israel.”
“Historical Zionism was primarily a religious movement.”
“Religious Zionism was dominant in historical Zionism.”
“It is impossible to tell whether hundreds of thousands or millions of Jews were killed.”
“There is no basis for Israel’s security concerns.”
“Zionism has always viewed Palestinians as inferiors.”
“Zionism has always viewed itself as colonialist.”
“Israel is a form of Christian colonialism.”
“Criticism of Zionism has never involved Anti-Jewish aversions.”
“Historical Zionism never described itself as an emancipatory enterprise.”
“There has never been an Arabist –Zionist conflict, only victimization of Palestinians.”
“There has never been a Muslim-Jewish conflict, only victimization of Palestinians.”
“To speak of a conflict between Israelis and “Arabs” constitutes defamation.”
“There was no notion of Jewish peoplehood before Zionism.”
“Jewish self-government in antique Israel was limited to a period of 62 years.”
“Jewish independence in antique Israel was limited to a period of 62 years.”
“Modern Israel itself is not a historically successful case of Arab-Jewish coexistence.”
“There is no history of Anti-Judaism in the Muslim world.”
“Rabbinical Jews are not native to Israel and the West Bank.”
“There is no historical Jewish continuity across the ages.”
“Jewish historical continuity is a 19th century nationalist construction.”
“There is no Israeli historical continuity with Roman-occupied Judea.”
“There was no Jewish nationalism prior to the 19th century.”
“Jewish historiography of suffering is irrational per se.”
“Jewish historiography of suffering is illegitimate per se.”
“Jewish historiography of suffering is illogical per se.”
“Jews are foreign/non-indigenous to the Near East.”
“Jews are foreign/non-indigenous to Israel.”
“Jews are foreign/non-indigenous to the West Bank.”
“There is no such thing as historical and/or contemporary Muslim Anti-Judaism.”
“Judaism emerged from Islam.”
“The ancient Israelis were Arabs.”
“The ancient Canaanites were Palestinians.”
“Bush attacked Iraq to build greater Israel so Jesus can return.”
“Zionists initiated the crusades.”
Assuming that the people of Israel had no titular nationality before Zionism.
Assuming that the people of Israel had no titular nationality in antiquity.
Assuming that the people of Israel had no titular nationality in medieval times.
Claiming that Lebanon officially regarded Har Dov as Lebanese before the year 2000. Claiming that Hizbollah officially regarded Har Dov as Lebanese before the year 2000.
Claiming that Iran officially regarded Har Dov as Lebanese before the year 2000.
Claiming that Amal officially regarded Har Dov as Lebanese before the year 2000.
Claiming that the UN officially regarded Har Dov as Lebanese before the year 2000.
Claiming that Israel initiated hostilities in the 1967 war.
Claiming that Tel Aviv has remained the capital of Israel.
Denying the existence of millennial Jewish nationalism.
Claiming that Palestinian suffering is due to the Holocaust.
Claiming that the Palestinians are the real victims of the Holocaust.
Claiming that he Holocaust is the raison d’être of Israel.
Claiming Zionism established Israel because of the Holocaust.
Claiming that Partition of the Mandate was proposed because of the Holocaust.
Claiming that it is impossible to approximate how many Jews died during WWII.
Claiming that America established Israel as compensation for the Holocaust.
Claiming that Europe established Israel as compensation for the Holocaust.
Claiming that Israel was established by gentiles.
Denying that rabbinical Jews shared a common history even before Zionism.
Denying that rabbinical Jews in part share a common genetic origin.
Denying that eventual return to Israel is a key tenet of rabbinical Judaism.
Denying that rabbinical Judaism always viewed Jews as a people.
Claiming that pre-modern rabbinical Judaism viewed itself as a mere religion.
Assuming that pre-Zionist Jews had no nationality of their own or at all.
Claiming that the Jewish Diaspora is a Christian invention.
Claiming that Zionism rewrote biblical history.
Claiming that Zionism rewrote medieval rabbinical Jewish history.
Denying that prayers for return to Israel is part of traditional rabbinical Jewish liturgy.
Claiming that Jewish historians believe the rabbinical Diaspora was created by Romans.
Claiming that Jewish historians believe that current Jews are “racially pure” Israelites.
Denying the historical existence of a Jewish people before the emergence of Zionism.
Claiming that the Jewish people was never in exile.
Denying that pre-state Zionist leaders generally advocated Jewish national liberation.
Denying that pre-state Zionist leaders were generally motivated by national liberation.
Claiming that Jewish nationality was not socially constructed before the 20th century.
Ignoring the existence of Jewish nationalism within the Roman Empire.
Ignoring the existence of Jewish ultra-nationalism within the Roman Empire.
Ignoring that nationalism is an ancient Jewish invention.
Claiming that Ashkenazi Jews deprived Mizrahi Jews of Arabist national identity.
Claiming that Mizrahi Jews generally used to identify as ethnic Arabists.
Claiming that Arabists generally viewed Mizrahi Jews as Arabs.
Claiming that Muslims generally viewed Mizrahi Jews as Arabs.
Claiming that Mizrahi Jews generally identified with Arabism.
Implying that Palestinians have generally viewed Mizrahi Jews as fellow Arabs.
Implying that Palestinians have generally welcomed Mizrahi Jews as fellow Arabs.
Implying that Mizrahi Jews generally were Arabists.
Implying that Mizrahi Jews generally were content with their legal status as Dhimmis.
Ignoring that Mizrahi Jews were second-class citizens on account of being Dhimmis.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally were part of gentile ethnicities.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally were part of gentile nationalities.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally had no ethnicities of their own.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally did not consider themselves a people.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally did not consider themselves a nation.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally considered themselves void of ethnicity.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally considered themselves void of nationality.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally considered themselves void of peoplehood.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry generally considered themselves void of nationhood.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Judean-language Jewry lived in a gentile paradise.
Claiming that the Jewish people is a figment of Christian imagination.
Claiming that the Jewish people is a gentile social construction.
Claiming that the Jewish people is a product of Christendom.
Claiming that the Jewish people is historically an agent of Christendom
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry had no historical agency.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry were gentiles by ethnic group membership.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry were gentiles by national group membership.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry considered themselves gentiles by ethnicity.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewry considered themselves gentiles by nationality.
Claiming that gentiles generally regarded pre-Zionist Jewry as gentiles by ethnicity.
Claiming that gentiles generally regarded pre-Zionist Jewry as gentiles by nationality.
Assuming that Jews of the Arabophone world were historically viewed as Arabs.
Claiming that Jews historically changed national identity when they switched language.
Claiming that pre-state Zionism lacked significant religious support.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to Israel.
Claiming that historical Zionism was based on “gathering the faithful”.
Claiming that Apartheid and Zionism were both founded on a single ethnicity.
Claiming that there was a Palestinian nation before it was articulated.
Claiming that there was a separate Palestinian ethnicity before it was articulated.
Claiming that Zionism “transformed a religion into a nation”.
Claiming that the phrase ‘a land without a people’ was widely used among Zionists.
Claiming that Pre-state Zionist leaders imagined an “exclusive” Jewish state.
Claiming that Israeli governments imagined an “exclusive” Jewish state.
Claiming that Palestinian was an Arab ethnonym prior to Palestinism.
Claiming that the “one-state solution” is a novel idea.
Assuming that pre-state bi-nationalism opposed the mainstream Zionist movement.
Claiming that the Israeli peace movement have not opposed Israeli occupation.
Claiming that Israel has never gained anything through the use of force.
Denying that Arabist leaders supported and facilitated the Holocaust.
Denying that the Palestinian leadership supported and facilitated the Holocaust.
Claiming that mainstream Zionism is founded on theocracy.
Claiming that pre-Zionist Jewish-Muslim co-existence was paradisiacal.
Claiming that pre-Israeli Jewish-Muslim co-existence was peaceful and egalitarian.
Claiming that rabbinical Jewish citizens were afforded equality under Muslim rule.
Claiming that there was no Anti-Jewish persecution in Muslim lands.
Claiming that Muslim rule afforded civic equality to Jews.
Claiming that Muslim rule afforded equal citizenship to Jews.
Claiming that there was never Anti-Judaism in Muslim culture.
Claiming that there was never Anti-Semitism in Muslim culture.
Claiming that the PLO has made final status concessions in the negotiations with Israel.
Claiming that the PLO has made final status concessions since after 1988.
Claiming that there was no relationship between Arabist and Zionist expulsions in 1948.
Claiming that there was no relationship between Arabist and Zionist expulsions in 1967.
Denying that Palestinists had a role in inciting Arabist expulsions of Jews.
Claiming that Zionist expulsions were one-sided.
Denying that Arabist and Zionist expulsions constituted actions in a mutual conflict.
Claiming that Afro-Asian Jewish and Palestinian demands for restitution are unrelated.
Claiming that the 1948 Nakba was one-sided rather than mutual.
Claiming that Gaza-Egypt border has been under Israel’s permanent control after 2005.
Claiming that Israel has controlled all Gaza region entry/exit points even after 2005.
Claiming that the one-state solution is a novel idea.
Claiming that the Jews are incapable of defeating the Muslim nation.
Claiming that the Jews are incapable of defeating the Arabist nation.
Claiming that the Jews are incapable of defeating the Palestinian nation.
Claiming that the UNGA generally sided with the Palestinian side before the 1970’s.
Claiming that Jews have always been well-treated in Muslim countries.
Claiming that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was caused by Jewish immigration.
Claiming that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict began in 1917.
Claiming that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict began in 1948.
Claiming that the Israel-Palestinian conflict began in 1967.
Claiming that Islam has historically accorded equality to Jews.
Claiming that the 1973 oil embargo was mere retaliation against Israel’s allies.
Claiming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were proper borders.
Claiming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were recognized borders.
Claiming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were legal borders.
Assuming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were seen as borders by Jordan.
Assuming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were seen as borders by Israel.
Assuming that Israel became internationally recognized within its armistice lines.
Assuming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were permanent borders.
Assuming that the West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were agreed permanent borders.
Assuming that the Arabophone world viewed the WB 1949-67 lines as legal borders.
Assuming that the Arab League viewed the West Bank 1949-67 lines as legal borders.
Assuming that the Arab League viewed the WB 1949-67 lines as legitimate borders.
Claiming that Jews who lived in Arabophone countries mostly identified as Arabists.
Claiming that Jews who lived in Arabophone countries largely identified as Arabists.
Claiming that Judean-language Jews largely identified as Arabists.
Claiming that Mizrahi Jews largely identified as Arabists.
Claiming that North African Jews largely identified as Arabists.
Claiming that Lebanese Jews largely identified as Arabists.
Claiming that Jews have generally been accorded equal status by political Islam.
Denying that Jews have been persecuted by Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been legally discriminated by Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been oppressed by Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been stigmatized by Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been libeled by Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been persecuted by Muslims throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been legally discriminated by Muslims throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been oppressed by Muslims throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been stigmatized by Muslims throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been massacred by Muslims throughout history
Denying that Jews have libeled by Muslims throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been libeled as murderers throughout history.
Claiming that there has never been Anti-Jewish hostility in the Muslim world.
Claiming that there has never been Anti-Jewish hostility in Islam.
Denying that Jews have been forcibly converted to Islam throughout history.
Denying that Jews have been forcibly converted by Muslims throughout history.
Claiming that the PLO cannot negotiate without a construction freeze.
Claiming that Israel-PLO agreements prohibit Jewish construction in disputed J’lem.
Claiming that Israel-PLO agreements prohibit Jewish construction in disputed WB.
Claiming that the Nabateans were Arabs originally.
Assuming that Palestinian diplomats file internal reports in English.
Assuming that Palestinian diplomats file domestic reports in English.
Claiming that Israel’s 1967 conquest of the West Bank caused the conflict.
Claiming that Israel’s 1967 conquest of the West Bank is the origin the conflict.
Claiming that the Palestinian nation precedes the Jews.
Claiming that the Arabist nation precedes the Jews.
Claiming that the Islamic nation precedes the Jews.
Claiming that Islam precedes the Jews.
Claiming that Palestine precedes Israel.
Claiming that Arabism precedes Zionism.
Denying the entire history of Muslim Anti-Judaism.
Denying the existence of Muslim Anti-Judaism.
Denying that Muslim Anti-Judaism is historically pervasive in Muslim culture.
Claiming that Muslims have never persecuted Jews.
Claiming that Jews invented the Shoah to get international support for Zionism.
Claiming that Israel committed a Shoah.
Claiming that Israel commits new Shoahs.
Claiming that Israel constantly commits new Shoahs.
Claiming that the 1949-67 Jordanian-Israeli armistice lines were recognized borders.
Claiming that West Bank 1949-67 armistice lines were internationally accepted borders.
Claiming that Palestinians are incapable of negotiating while Jews builds in the WB.
Claiming that the PA has always rejected terrorism.
Claiming that the PLO has always rejected terrorism.
Claiming that the Palestinist movement has always rejected terrorism.
Claiming that the Palestinist movement has never engaged in acts of terrorism.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to Judea.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to Israel.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to the West Bank.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to East Jerusalem.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to Jerusalem.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to the Gaza region.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to the Golan.
Denying that Jews are indigenous to Samaria.
Assuming that any account is true if it is part of the Palestinist historical narrative.
Assuming that any account is legitimate if it is part of the Palestinist historical narrative.
Assuming that the Jewish state would not exist if it was poor rather than affluent.
Claiming that Arabist persecution of Jews was unrelated to the Palestinian dispute.
Claiming that Arabist expulsion of Jews was unrelated to the Palestinian dispute.
Claiming that the Zionist-Arabist conflict is unrelated to the Palestinian dispute.
Claiming that Arabist expulsions of Jews were unrelated to the Palestinian dispute.
Claiming that Arabist persecution of Jews was unrelated to the Palestinian dispute.
Claiming that agreements with the PLO prevents any return to hostilities.
Claiming that Israeli poverty leads to increased Israeli respect for Israel’s enemies.
Claiming that Israeli international isolation would lead Israel to esteem its enemies.
Claiming that Anti-Jewish prejudice did not historically exist in Muslim lands.
Claiming that Anti-Jewish oppression did not historically exist in the Muslim world.
Claiming that Anti-Jewish persecution did not historically exist in the Muslim world.
Claiming that there is no history of Muslim Anti-Judaism.
Claiming that Muslim Anti-Jewish aversions were solely imported from Europe.
Claiming that Muslim/Jewish coexistence was a paradise prior to Zionism.
Claiming that the 1947 UN Partition plan did not support Jewish statehood.
Claiming that frontier walls are indicative of Apartheid.
Describing the Israeli-Jordanian 1949 armistice lines as “the 1967 borders.”
Describing the Israeli-Jordanian 1949 armistice lines as “the 1967 lines.”
“The 1947 UN Partition plan made the Palestinian migration unavoidable.”
“Israeli independence made the Palestinian migration unavoidable.”
Denying that Jordan is a demographically de facto Palestinian majority state.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to Israel.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to the West Bank.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to East Jerusalem.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to the Golan.
Claiming that Jews are not indigenous to Hebron.
“Jews did not live in the West Bank prior to the foundation of Israel in 1948.”
“Jews did not live in the East Jerusalem prior to the foundation of Israel in 1948.”
Denying that the 1948 war generated fleeing refugees in both directions.
Claiming that the ‘48 war increased Jewish ownership of land in the Arabophone world.
Claiming that “BDS” is a grassroots initiative.
Claiming that Hebrew culture is not indigenous to Israel.
“The 1948 Jewish exodus from Muslim lands was unrelated to Anti-Zionism.”
“The Jewish and Palestinians exoduses of 1948 were unrelated.”
“Anti-Zionist persecution of Jews had no relationship to the Palestinian cause.”
“Palestinian property claims are unrelated to Mizrahi Jewish property claims.”
Denying that 1948 Muslim persecution of Jews was intrinsically Anti-Zionist.
Denying that 1948 Arabist persecution of Jews was intrinsically Anti-Zionist.
Denying that Palestinian collaboration with the Nazis was intrinsically Anti-Zionist.
“The WB barrier was built so as to delineate Israel’s territorial claims.”
“The WB barrier was built so institute racial segregation.”
Assuming that most Israeli WB communities are on the western side of the barrier.
Assuming that most of the WB population on the western side of the barrier are Jewish.
Assuming that the WB barrier provides absolute Jewish/Palestinian separation.
Assuming that there are no Palestinian communities west of the WB barrier.
Assuming that there are no Jewish communities east of the WB barrier.
Assuming that the WB barrier established racial separation.
Claiming that it is intrinsically racist to narrate the history of Talmudic Jews.
Claiming that an account is true because it is Neo-Philistine.
Claiming that a narrative is true because it is Neo-Philistine.
Assuming that Israel was created by gentiles as compensation for the Shoah.

Return to Typology of Antivrism